Is André Onana a Valuable Addition or Potential Risk for Manchester United?

Andrew Onana Mistakes

Onana is a modern goalkeeper with a lot of potential. He is good at playing with his feet and is very good at sweeping up behind his defense. However, he has only kept two clean sheets in his first ten appearances for Man United. This has led to some people questioning whether he is a liability or an asset to the club.

Those who believe that Onana is a liability point to his lack of clean sheets as evidence. They argue that a good goalkeeper should be able to keep more clean sheets, especially in a team like Man United that is expected to win most of their games. They also point to some of the mistakes he has made, such as the one that led to Chelsea's goal in their recent match.

Those who believe that Onana is an asset point to his potential and his overall performances. They argue that he is still adapting to the Premier League and that he will improve with time. They also point to his strengths, such as his distribution and his ability to come off his line.

Ultimately, whether Onana is a liability or an asset to Man United is a matter of opinion. There is no right or wrong answer. However, it is clear that he is a talented goalkeeper with a lot of potential. It will be interesting to see how he develops in the coming months and years.

Here is a more detailed contrast of the two arguments:


  • Lack of clean sheets
  • Mistakes


  • Potential
  • Overall performances
  • Distribution
  • Ability to come off his line

It is important to note that Onana is still a young goalkeeper and is still adapting to the Premier League. It is also important to note that he has been playing in a Man United team that has been struggling defensively this season. Despite these challenges, Onana has shown some promising signs and has the potential to be a very good goalkeeper for Man United in the future.